All Filters
Applied Filters
Our AI is always learning and some details weren’t matched. You can still try them as keyword searches:
Price
Beds

Select two tiles for min/max range

Baths
Transit Lines
Home Type
Home Styles
Specialty Housing

Housing Type

Short-Term

Additional Specialties

Pet Policy
Move-In Date
Popular Amenities
Schools Rating
School data provided by (opens in new window/tab) The GreatSchools Rating summarizes school quality based on student progress, college readiness, and test scores.
Renter Rating
Show Only
Keyword
Searching for student living options?

Select your school and find the perfect place nearby or on-campus.

All Universities
Pricing Type
Amenities
Clear
Nearby

2 Bedroom Apartments for Rent Near Shelter Island NY

169 Rentals Available

We expanded your search area to show more results.

2 Bedroom Shelter Island, NY Apartments for Rent

Browse 169 two-bedroom apartments for rent in Shelter Island, NY on Apartments.com, ideal for roommates or anyone looking for extra space. Whether you're working from home, need room for guests or hobbies, or just want more flexibility, there are various two-bedroom Shelter Island apartment options to suit your needs. Use our customizable filters to easily select features that matter most in a two-bedroom—like private bathrooms or extra closet space—and browse layouts that match your needs. For an up-close experience, select the “3D Tour” filter and explore each unit through an immersive Matterport digital walkthrough. Start your search today and find a home where your next chapter begins.

Learn more about living in Shelter Island, NY

Search Nearby Rentals

2 Bedroom Rentals Near Shelter ...

Neighborhood Apartment Rentals

Nearby Shelter Island House ...

New Rental Listings

Map Options
Map View
Default
Satellite
Nearby Point of Interests
Travel Time

Set a destination, transportation method, and your ideal commute time to see results.

Under 30 minutes

Commute Time is calculated at rush hour.