Bay Shore Manor
2 Garfield St,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
$1,895 - $2,500
1-2 Beds
Downtown Bay Shore
Bay Shore, NY
Downtown Bay Shore - Bay Shore, NY
Area Guide
The eclectic heart of Bay Shore
Walkable
•
Vibrant
•
Historic
•
Charming
•
Scenic
•
Convenient
•
Downtown Bay Shore is the cultural heart of the community, boasting a bevy of unique shops, diverse restaurants, and local offices in red-brick storefronts lining a charming strip of Montauk Highway. The YMCA Boulton Center for the Performing Arts is located in the neighborhood, hosting numerous concerts and live performances throughout the year.
A wide variety of apartments, townhomes, and houses are available for rent within walking distance of Downtown Bay Shore’s commercial core. Many rentals in the neighborhood are also proximate to the great recreational opportunities at Bay Shore Manor Park, providing the best of urban convenience and natural coastal beauty. Getting around from Downtown Bay Shore is a breeze with access to the Long Island Rail Road’s Montauk Line, Fire Island Ferries, and Sunrise Highway.
Rent Trends
As of September 2025, the average apartment rent in Downtown Bay Shore is $2,206 for a studio, $2,618 for one bedroom, $3,220 for two bedrooms, and $4,424 for three bedrooms. Apartment rent in Downtown Bay Shore has increased by 2.0% in the past year.
-
Studio
-
495 sq ft
Average Sq Ft
-
$2,206/month
Average Rent
-
1 BR
-
664 sq ft
Average Sq Ft
-
$2,618/month
Average Rent
-
2 BR
-
979 sq ft
Average Sq Ft
-
$3,220/month
Average Rent
-
3 BR
-
1,401 sq ft
Average Sq Ft
-
$4,424/month
Average Rent
Transportation
69
Very Walkable
out of 100 WalkScore® Rating
If you enjoy walking, you’ll enjoy renting in this area! It’s a very walkable neighborhood.
57
Bikeable
out of 100 BikeScore® Rating
While there’s some bike infrastructure in this area, you’ll still need a car for many errands.
Points of Interest
Shopping Centers
Parks and Recreation
- Gardiner County Park
- Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park
- Heckscher State Park
- Belmont Lake State Park
- Captree State Park
Military Bases
Airports
- Long Island MacArthur
- John F Kennedy International
Top Apartments in Downtown Bay Shore
Houses for Rent in Downtown Bay Shore
Property Management Companies
Greystar
-
3,381
Communities
-
938,909
Units
-
867
Cities
Willow Bridge
-
698
Communities
-
189,489
Units
-
330
Cities
AMC
-
674
Communities
-
132,053
Units
-
263
Cities
RPM
-
623
Communities
-
167,920
Units
-
242
Cities
FPI Management
-
619
Communities
-
106,039
Units
-
220
Cities
Cushman & Wakefield
-
530
Communities
-
122,197
Units
-
271
Cities
Search Nearby Rentals
Nearby City Rentals
Nearby Neighborhood Rentals
Methodology
† Our analysis of utilities, groceries, transportation, healthcare, home prices, and other goods and services is sourced from the Cost of Living Index, a respected benchmark published by the Council for Community and Economic Research (C2ER) that provides a thorough overview of living expenses across different regions.
Rent data is provided by CoStar Group’s Market Trend reports. As the industry leader in commercial real estate information, analytics, and news, CoStar conducts extensive research to produce and maintain a comprehensive database of commercial real estate information. We combine this data with public record to provide the most up-to-date rental information available.
Consumer goods, services, and home prices are sourced from the Cost of Living Index published by the Council for Community and Economic Research (C2ER). The data on this page is updated quarterly. It was last published in September 2025.