Background Image

Area Guide

Annadale Staten Island, NY

Annadale delivers a quieter, more suburban slice of Staten Island's South Shore, where streets stretch from wooded green space down toward the Atlantic Ocean. Daily life here revolves around tree-lined residential streets, local eateries clustered near the Annadale station, and the expansive Blue Heron Park Wildlife Preserve anchoring the neighborhood's west side. The area is moderately easy to get around on foot for nearby errands, and the greenery coverage is exceptional -- giving residents a sense of space that's harder to come by in denser parts of New York City.

Apartment rentals in Annadale are scarce and scattered rather than concentrated, showing up as small multi-family buildings tucked among the single-family blocks rather than dedicated complexes. What's there stays strictly low-rise, matching the postwar scale of the surrounding houses. A handful sit within reach of the Annadale train station, giving renters a rare car-free commute option in a part of the island otherwise built around driving.

Annadale sits on Staten Island's South Shore, roughly equidistant from the more commercial stretches of Eltingville to the east and Arden Heights to the north. The Staten Island Railway's Annadale station connects residents to St. George and the free Staten Island Ferry for access to Lower Manhattan, making this suburban setting more connected to city life than its peaceful streets might suggest.

Learn More About Annadale

Getting Around

Fairly Walkable

Walkability

50 / 100

Some Public Transit

Transit

50 / 100

Moderately Drivable

Drivability

60 / 100

Moderately Bikeable

Bikeability

60 / 100

Daily Essentials

Supermarket Within a 20 Minute Walk

Groceries

50 / 100

Good Restaurant Variety Nearby

Restaurants

60 / 100

Fair Café Variety Nearby

Cafes

40 / 100

Fair Variety of Shops Nearby

Shopping

40 / 100

Recreation

Exceptional Amount of Park Space Nearby

Parks

100 / 100

Fair Wellness Amenity Variety Nearby

Wellness

50 / 100

Local Vibe

Mostly Calm Atmosphere

Vibrancy

20 / 100

Fair Nightlife Variety Nearby

Nightlife

40 / 100

Not Noisy

Quiet Score

90 / 100

Points of Interest

Parks and Recreation

  • Blue Heron Park and Center
  • Wolfes Pond Park
  • Seaside Wildlife Nature Park
  • Bloomingdale Park
  • Lemon Creek Park

Airports

  • Newark Liberty International
  • John F Kennedy International

Living in Annadale

Restaurants

-

Most of Annadale's dining options are concentrated on the streets near the Staten Island Railway station on the neighborhood's north end and in a nearby strip mall. The scene covers a comfortable range of everyday tastes, with breakfast spots, Italian entrees and pizza, and Japanese cuisine all represented within the neighborhood itself.

Along Hylan Boulevard closer to the water, a local diner and an Italian restaurant round out the options for residents who prefer to eat near home. Grocery shopping is most convenient at stores in the neighboring communities of Eltingville to the east and Arden Heights to the north.

Transportation

-

Getting around Annadale is most practical by car, with Hylan Boulevard and the Korean War Veterans Parkway providing the main local routes. The Veterans Parkway connects to the Staten Island Expressway, which reaches Brooklyn via the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge and New Jersey beyond that, with Newark Airport only about 5 miles from the island's edge.

The Staten Island Railway's Annadale station gives residents a car-free option for reaching St. George, where the free Staten Island Ferry crosses to Lower Manhattan. That combined trip runs at least an hour, but it is a reliable daily commute route. Interborough bus service offers an alternative for those who prefer not to transfer between rail and ferry.

Parks

-

Blue Heron Park Wildlife Preserve covers a substantial portion of Annadale's west side, offering wooded hiking trails, a playground, and a nature center that hosts educational programming throughout the year. The preserve's exceptional greenery makes it a true backyard amenity for residents on the surrounding streets.

At the neighborhood's north end, Drumgoole Tot Lot provides a playground for outdoor recreation, and the Arden Heights Woods just beyond the neighborhood boundary supports additional hiking. Beach activities are most accessible at Midland Beach and South Beach, both reachable from Annadale for a fuller coastal outing.

Shopping

-

A strip mall near the Staten Island Railway station anchors Annadale's commercial life, with a handful of local businesses and delis covering everyday needs. For broader retail options, the Staten Island Mall is within a short drive to the northwest, offering department stores and national retailers in one central location.

The South Shore Business Improvement District is active in the area, organizing community events around the Annadale station that bring residents together near the neighborhood's main commercial strip. Grocery runs are easiest at the Stop & Shop in neighboring Eltingville or the Key Food in Arden Heights.

Highlights

-

Exceptional green space, a quiet residential character, and a direct rail-and-ferry link to Lower Manhattan make Annadale one of Staten Island's more appealing South Shore addresses.

Search Nearby Rentals

Methodology

† Our analysis of utilities, groceries, transportation, healthcare, home prices, and other goods and services is sourced from the Cost of Living Index, a respected benchmark published by the Council for Community and Economic Research (C2ER) that provides a thorough overview of living expenses across different regions.

Rent data is provided by CoStar Group’s Market Trend reports. As the industry leader in commercial real estate information, analytics, and news, CoStar conducts extensive research to produce and maintain a comprehensive database of commercial real estate information. We combine this data with public record to provide the most up-to-date rental information available.

Consumer goods, services, and home prices are sourced from the Cost of Living Index published by the Council for Community and Economic Research (C2ER). The data on this page is updated quarterly. It was last published in September 2026.

Demographic information comes from Neustar and combines detailed address data with U.S. Census and American Community Survey statistics to produce reliable local estimates.