Houses New York Suffolk County Shelter Island Eastern Suffolk

$7,500 / Month

42 N Menantic Rd

Shelter Island, NY 11964

Today

| Edit

631-477-5990

Bedrooms

4
Bathrooms

2.5
Square Feet

2,825 sq ft
Available

Available Now

Highlights

In Ground Pool
Eat-In Gourmet Kitchen
Electrolux Appliances
Contemporary Architecture
Radiant Floor
Wood Flooring

42 N Menantic Rd

About This Home

$7,500 deposit, Available Now

Escape to Tranquility Base,a light-filled modern retreat where timeless mid-century style meets today’s elevated comforts. Thoughtfully renovated and expanded,this 4-bedroom,2.5-bath home is surrounded by lush,landscaped grounds and designed for seamless indoor–outdoor living—thanks to five sliding glass doors that open to a heated gunite pool and expansive entertaining deck. Enjoy the Shelter Island lifestyle at this completely renovated,Contemporary home It will serve as both your quiet sanctuary away from city life and a place to entertain. When it is time to explore,beaches,farm stands,seafood shops,and celebrated Shelter Island restaurants are all within easy reach. Savor the excellent restaurants or make your own home-cooked meals on the 5-burner Jenn-Air gas stove or outdoor gas grill. Full kitchen with all amenities including granite center island,Electrolux Icon appliances. There is a large capacity washer/dryer off kitchen. Lounge on the large,sectional sofa in the living room with gas fireplace. The house features 2 systems for central heat and A/C with Nest thermostats. The bedrooms consist of one King Bed in Primary Bedroom with en-suite Carrera marble bathroom; 2 twin beds in 2nd bedroom with full bathroom,shower and tub and 3rd bedroom with comfortable,Queen sleeper sofa. A 4th Bedroom on lower level features a Queen Bed and home office. The lower level also features a kitchenette,living area and ping pong table. A half-bath is off the main kitchen and dining room. Play your favorite songs on 2 Sonos systems in the living room and pool deck. A T-shaped driveway provides ample parking for up to 5 cars. Available Winter Rate January 1st to June 30th $7500 PER MONTH. Rental Reg.#2024-L-0124 Photos coming soon. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of [see last changed date above]. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. Prices displayed on all Sold listings are the Last Known Listing Price and may not be the actual selling price.

42 N Menantic Rd is a house located in Suffolk County and the 11964 ZIP Code. This area is served by the Shelter Island Union Free attendance zone.

* Price shown is base rent. Excludes user-selected optional fees and variable or usage-based fees and required charges due at or prior to move-in or at move-out. Price, availability, fees, and any applicable rent special are subject to change without notice.

* Square footage definitions vary. Displayed square footage is approximate.

Home Details

Home Type

Single Family Detached Home

Year Built

Built in 1949

Bedrooms and Bathrooms

Main Floor Bedroom Bathroom on Main Level En-Suite Primary Bedroom 2.5 Bathrooms 4 Bedrooms

Finished Basement

Basement Fills Entire Space Under The House

Flooring

Radiant Floor Wood Tile

Home Design

Contemporary Architecture Shingle Siding Stone Siding Entry on the 1st floor

Home Security

Smart Thermostat

Interior Spaces

High Ceiling Furnished Indoor Speakers Sound System Entrance Foyer Chandelier Ceiling Fan Gas Fireplace 2,825 Sq Ft Home

Kitchen

Eat-In Gourmet Kitchen Electrolux Appliances Granite Countertops Stainless Steel Appliances Convection Oven Breakfast Bar Kitchen Island Gas Cooktop Freezer Microwave Dishwasher

Laundry

Dryer Washer

Listing and Financial Details

6-Month Minimum Lease Term Assessor Parcel Number 0700-014-00-03-00-058-001 Rent includes grounds care

Lot Details

0.86 Acre Lot

Outdoor Features

Outdoor Gas Grill

Parking

Driveway 5 Parking Spaces

Pool

In Ground Pool Outdoor Pool Fence Around Pool

Schools

Shelter Island Elementary And Middle School Shelter Island High School

Utilities

Forced Air Heating and Cooling System Propane Cable TV Available Well Electric Water Heater Septic Tank Heating System Uses Oil Cesspool Vented Exhaust Fan Heating System Uses Propane

Community Details

Pet Policy

Call for details about the types of pets allowed

Fees and Policies

The fees below are based on community-supplied data and may exclude additional fees and utilities.

One-Time Basics
- Due at Move-In
  - Security Deposit - Refundable
    
    $7,500

Property Fee Disclaimer: Based on community-supplied data and independent market research. Subject to change without notice. May exclude fees for mandatory or optional services and usage-based utilities.

Contact

Listed by Jean Marie Bay | William Raveis New York LLC
Phone Number
Contact
Source

OneKey® MLS

Information Copyright 2026, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS.

Location Get Directions

Schools Restaurants Groceries Coffee Banks Shops Fitness

Amenities

Air Conditioning

Smoke Free

City - Shelter Island

Nicknamed “the un-Hamptons,” Shelter Island is a peaceful island community situated on the eastern end of Long Island. Shelter Island is only accessible by ferry and sits just five minutes from its bustling neighbor, the Hamptons. Adorned with old-fashioned buildings along tree-lined streets, Shelter Island exudes small-town charm and tranquil luxury in equal measure.

The community’s secluded feel is a part of its allure, despite being within close reach of wine country and the Hamptons. Shelter Island is also roughly a two-hour drive from New York City. Shelter Island’s rental homes generally offer quick access to the community’s many beaches as well as the locally owned shops and restaurants that line Ferry Road.

Learn more about living in Shelter Island

Education

Colleges & Universities			Distance
Colleges & Universities			Distance
SUNY Suffolk Co., Eastern	Drive:	66 min	29.2 mi
Connecticut College	Drive:	131 min	31.6 mi
University of Connecticut	Drive:	139 min	35.4 mi
Yale University, Main Campus	Drive:	190 min	77.9 mi

42 N Menantic Rd is within 66 minutes or 29.2 miles from SUNY Suffolk Co., Eastern. It is also near Connecticut College and University of Connecticut.

Schools

Shelter Island School

Public Elementary, Middle & High School

Grades PK-12

174 Students

Attendance Zone

The Hayground School

Private Elementary & Middle School

Grades PK-8

77 Students

Nearby

Our Lady Of Mercy Regional School

Private Elementary School

Grades PK-6

92 Students

Nearby

School data provided by

Transportation

42 N Menantic Rd is near Tweed/New Haven, located 74.9 miles or 186 minutes away.

Commuter Rail			Distance
Commuter Rail			Distance
Greenport Station	Drive:	20 min	3.0 mi
Southold Station	Drive:	28 min	7.2 mi
Bridgehampton Station	Drive:	39 min	11.8 mi
East Hampton Station	Drive:	42 min	13.8 mi
Mattituck Station	Drive:	40 min	15.4 mi

Airports			Distance
Airports			Distance
Tweed/New Haven	Drive:	186 min	74.9 mi

Car-Dependent

Walk Score^®

Out of 100

This area is considered a car-dependent area and most errands will require a car.

Minimal Transit

Transit Score^®

Out of 100

Somewhat Bikeable

Bike Score^®

Out of 100

You might be able to find places to ride your bike in this area, but you’ll most likely want your car for most errands.

Soundscore^™

Out of 100

Traffic:

Airport:

Businesses:

Score provided by

Scores provided by and

Score provided by

Points of Interest

Time and distance from 42 N Menantic Rd.

Shopping Centers			Distance
Shopping Centers			Distance
Southold Square	Drive:	28 min	7.2 mi
Village Of Southold	Drive:	28 min	7.2 mi
Lighthouse Center	Drive:	29 min	7.8 mi

42 N Menantic Rd has 3 shopping centers within 7.8 miles, which is about a 29-minute drive. The miles and minutes will be for the farthest away property.

Parks and Recreation			Distance
Parks and Recreation			Distance
East End Seaport Maritime Museum	Drive:	20 min	2.9 mi
Red House Nature Center	Drive:	23 min	4.2 mi
Custer Institute Observatory	Drive:	30 min	8.3 mi
Orient Beach State Park	Drive:	46 min	13.6 mi
Cedar Point County Park	Drive:	52 min	15.0 mi

42 N Menantic Rd has 5 parks within 15.0 miles, including East End Seaport Maritime Museum, Red House Nature Center, and Custer Institute Observatory.