Background Image

Carthage, NY

Area Guide

Avg Rent

$646

Population

3,451

Renter Mix

55% Rent

A riverside village in the foothills of the Adirondacks

Charming Historic River

Carthage is a small village tucked along the Black River in Jefferson County, part of upstate New York’s wide-open north country, where the Adirondack Mountains rise to the east and Lake Ontario stretches out to the west. Originally settled around 1798 under the name Long Falls, the village was formally chartered in 1869 and carries a genuine sense of history through its downtown architecture and close-knit character.

Fort Drum, one of the largest U.S. Army installations in the Northeast, sits just north of town and serves as a significant economic and employment anchor for the surrounding region. The Thousand Islands corridor and Beartown State Forest are both within easy reach, making outdoor recreation a natural part of daily life here.

Housing in Carthage leans toward traditional stock, with single-family rentals, modest multi-unit buildings, and apartment communities that reflect the village’s small-town scale and affordability compared to larger New York cities. The rental market is accessible, offering options ranging from compact one-bedroom units to spacious multi-bedroom homes.

Carthage sits roughly an hour northeast of Watertown and draws renters who want a quieter pace without losing proximity to regional employment hubs, natural landscapes, and a community with real roots.

Demographics

Median Household Income

$57,902

Average: $69,847

Education

618

Residents Have a Degree

Job Market

1,181

Workers Employed

Age Distribution
Get a sense of this area's population profile.

Median Age

34 Years

Largest Age Group

5-14 Years

Approximately 15% of Residents

Under 20

29%

Over 65

16%

Housing Distribution

Carthage has more renters than homeowners.

Renters
55%
Non-Renters
45%

Education Distribution

Review this city's overall education levels.

Bachelor's or Higher
16%
Other Education
84%

Rent Trends

As of June 2026, the average apartment rent in Carthage, NY is $646 for one bedroom, $1,110 for two bedrooms, and $1,429 for three bedrooms. Apartment rent in Carthage has increased by 0.3% in the past year.

Property Type
Average Rent
Average Sq Ft
Apartment
$646/month
498 Sq Ft
See Rental Market Trends in Carthage, NY

Getting Around

Somewhat Walkable

Walkability

30 / 100

Exceptionally Drivable

Drivability

90 / 100

Somewhat Bikeable

Bikeability

20 / 100

Schools

Carthage Middle School

Public

Grades K-8

925 Students

Carthage Elementary School

Public

Grades K-5

394 Students

West Carthage Elementary School

Public

Grades K-5

390 Students

Carthage Middle School

Public

Grades K-8

925 Students

Carthage Senior High School

Public

Grades 9-12

888 Students

Points of Interest

Shopping Centers

Parks and Recreation

  • Beartown State Forest (NY)
  • Onjebonge State Forest

Top Apartments in Carthage

Houses for Rent in Carthage

Living in Carthage

History

-

Carthage traces its origins to the early 19th century when the Black River’s waterpower drew settlers and entrepreneurs to northern New York. The village grew as a manufacturing center, particularly known for paper mills and dairy production that shaped its economy for generations. Today, you can still see this industrial heritage in historic brick buildings throughout downtown, many of which have been repurposed for shops, offices, and community spaces. The waterfront along the Black River offers visible reminders of the town’s milling past, while the surrounding residential streets showcase well-preserved Victorian and early 20th-century homes that reflect Carthage’s prosperous manufacturing era. As the seat of Jefferson County, Carthage maintains a collection of historic government buildings that speak to its long-standing role as a regional hub in the North Country.

Transportation

-

Most Carthage residents rely on personal vehicles for daily travel, with Route 26 and Route 3 serving as the main roads connecting Carthage to neighboring communities like Watertown and beyond. Public transit options are limited, as is typical of smaller rural communities in the region. Watertown International Airport, located roughly 20 miles away, provides regional air access. The compact size of the village makes walking practical for errands and local destinations, and the scenic Black River corridor offers opportunities for leisurely outdoor activity on foot or by bike.

Parks

-

Carthage offers residents access to a variety of outdoor spaces along the scenic Black River. Riverside Park is a local favorite, providing a peaceful waterfront setting ideal for picnics, fishing, and relaxing walks along the river. The surrounding Jefferson County region is rich with natural recreation opportunities, including easy access to the Adirondack Park, one of the largest protected natural areas in the United States, just a short drive away. Whether you enjoy hiking forested trails, paddling calm waterways, or simply soaking in the beauty of upstate New York’s outdoors, Carthage puts nature comfortably within reach.

Highlights

-

Carthage is a small village nestled along the Black River in Jefferson County, offering a close-knit community atmosphere with access to the natural beauty of upstate New York. Situated near Fort Drum, the area benefits from a stable local economy and steady demand for housing. Outdoor enthusiasts enjoy the proximity to the Adirondacks, rivers, and abundant recreational opportunities year-round. With affordable living costs, convenient access to Watertown, and a charming small-town setting, Carthage presents an appealing option for those seeking a peaceful and affordable place to call home.

Search Nearby Rentals

Methodology

† Our analysis of utilities, groceries, transportation, healthcare, home prices, and other goods and services is sourced from the Cost of Living Index, a respected benchmark published by the Council for Community and Economic Research (C2ER) that provides a thorough overview of living expenses across different regions.

Rent data is provided by CoStar Group’s Market Trend reports. As the industry leader in commercial real estate information, analytics, and news, CoStar conducts extensive research to produce and maintain a comprehensive database of commercial real estate information. We combine this data with public record to provide the most up-to-date rental information available.

Consumer goods, services, and home prices are sourced from the Cost of Living Index published by the Council for Community and Economic Research (C2ER). The data on this page is updated quarterly. It was last published in June 2026.

Demographic information comes from Neustar and combines detailed address data with U.S. Census and American Community Survey statistics to produce reliable local estimates.