401 Hunter Ave

About This Home

A rare opportunity to rent a DESIGNER'S HOME in PRIME City Island location-available both SHORT-TERM (August 15 - April 15, 2027) or LONG-TERM (one year +) either fully furnished as shown ($5,900 / month), or unfurnished (long-term only) to make it your own! - Keep your place in Manhattan, and have your beach retreat at a quick, stress-free distance where you can make full use of this property either part-time or full-time. Enjoy this true beachside retreat just 23 minutes from Manhattan. Whether you choose to live at 401 Hunter Avenue full-time or split your time between the city and this charming waterfront community, the convenience is unmatched. With easy access by car, train, express bus, or subway (via Pelham Bay Park), City Island offers the perfect balance of escape and accessibility. 401 Hunter Ave is perfectly positioned in one of the island's most desirable spots, this home offers privacy, charm, and tranquility while remaining just a short walk from shops, dining, and everyday conveniences. Set on a corner lot only two houses from the water, this beautifully renovated two-story residence features an open, flowing layout with soaring 10-foot ceilings and preserved pre-war character. An abundance of natural light from a plethora of large windows overlooking the yard, deck, and water views. The expansive first floor serves as the heart of the home, seamlessly connecting to a generous deck-ideal for entertaining, sunbathing, and relaxing. As an open-exposure property, the entire home is filled with light from sunrise to sunset, with particularly stunning sunsets enjoyed from the deck. The flexible layout allows you to tailor this home to your needs. The current office can function as a third bedroom, and the dining and living areas can be interchanged. The bright rear porch offers a perfect setting for a home office or fitness space, and the welcoming front porch provides a practical and inviting entry. The second floor features two generously sized bedrooms designed for both comfort and privacy. The airy, fully equipped kitchen features a double refrigerator and freezer, a six-burner chef's gas range, dishwasher, microwave, ample cabinetry for storage, and a standalone pantry. The 50 x 100 property includes a two- to three-car driveway, and a fenced yard. Homes of this caliber rarely (never really!) come to market for rent on City Island. Additional features include smart home technology, three-zoned central HVAC (plus radiators), ceiling fans in every room, security cameras, large capacity washer and vented dryer in the basement, a second refrigerator/freezer, and abundant storage. The basement is accessible from both the interior and a separate side entrance next to the driveway. Residents enjoy access to a private beach, yacht clubs - my favorite one next door; Harlem Yacht Club, numerous restaurants, markets, local shops, a Yoga & Pilates studio, a private gym, library, local Pre-K through 12th-grade school, post office, Chase bank etc. Nearby amenities also include the coveted New York Athletic Club, two golf courses, and horse stables - just minutes away along scenic Shore Road. Neighboring Orchard Beach, with its trails, walking & cycling paths, expansive shoreline, and the historic Bartow-Pell Mansion Museum - further enhances this exceptional lifestyle. City Island is known for its friendly, walkable, and bikeable community atmosphere-and yes, pets are very welcome! Excellent credit and references required. Private showings are available upon request by contacting the listing broker. This property is broker owned. Photos, floor plans, and walk-through video included.