2644 E Sherman Hollow Rd

About This Home

Nestled in the heart of New York’s breathtaking Finger Lakes region, just 1 mile from the charming village of Penn Yan, this spacious and inviting 1-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers the perfect blend of rural tranquility and convenient access to local amenities. Spanning an impressive 1,575 square feet on a generous 2-acre lot, this property provides ample room to breathe, relax, and enjoy the natural beauty that defines Yates County living. As you approach the home, you’ll be greeted by expansive grounds that stretch out across 2 acres of level, usable land—ideal for gardening, outdoor recreation, or simply soaking in the peaceful surroundings. The property features a convenient dog fence attached directly to the house, making it pet-friendly (with approval for animals). Imagine letting your furry companions roam safely while you unwind on the porch, watching the seasons change over the rolling hills and distant glimpses of the Finger Lakes landscape. Step inside to discover a thoughtfully designed interior that maximizes comfort and functionality. The home boasts a generous master bedroom complete with a large walk-in closet, providing abundant storage for clothing, shoes, and personal items. An additional attic space offers even more room for seasonal decorations, luggage, or hobby supplies, ensuring you’ll never feel cramped. With two full bathrooms, morning routines are a breeze, offering privacy and convenience for residents and guests alike. One of the standout features is the attached room dedicated as a home office—perfect for remote workers, students, or anyone needing a quiet, productive space separate from the main living areas. Whether you’re managing a home-based business, studying, or pursuing creative projects, this versatile room with natural light and seclusion will become your go-to sanctuary. The open and airy layout of the 1,575 square feet includes comfortable living spaces, a well-appointed kitchen, and dining areas that flow seamlessly, making it easy to entertain or enjoy quiet evenings at home. Large windows frame views of the surrounding acreage, bringing the outdoors in and creating a serene atmosphere year-round. Location is everything, and this property shines in that regard. Just 1 mile from the village of Penn Yan, you’ll have quick access to the vibrant downtown with its historic Main Street lined with unique shops, cafes, restaurants, and pubs. Penn Yan, named for its early Pennsylvania and Yankee settlers, is a quintessential small town recognized as one of America’s best for small-town living. Here, you can stroll along tree-lined streets, visit local breweries, or pick up fresh produce at Mennonite markets. The village sits at the northern tip of stunning Keuka Lake, one of the Finger Lakes’ most picturesque Y-shaped bodies of water, known for its crystal-clear waters, surrounding vineyards, and the renowned Keuka Lake Wine Trail. Families will appreciate the proximity to education: Penn Yan Academy (high school) and Penn Yan Middle School are nearby, part of the well-regarded Penn Yan Central School District. For higher education, Keuka College is only about 5 miles away, offering a beautiful lakeside campus and community events. Outdoor enthusiasts will love being minutes from the Keuka Outlet Trail, a scenic 7-mile path for hiking, biking, or running, complete with waterfalls and historic sites. Keuka Lake itself provides endless opportunities for boating, fishing, swimming at public beaches like Red Jacket Park, or exploring the wine trail’s family-owned wineries. The Finger Lakes region is famous for its natural beauty, four-season recreation, and welcoming community—making this rental an ideal base for experiencing it all. Rental Details: Monthly rent is $1,600. A $1,500 security deposit is required. Tenants must pay the first month’s rent and security deposit prior to move-in. This is a 12-month lease. Pets are allowed pending approval. To schedule a showing, please complete the rental application first. This property offers a rare combination of space, privacy, and location in one of New York’s most desirable areas—don’t miss your chance to make it your home!