• Primary Photo - 2 Prospect Ave
  • Building Photo - 2 Prospect Ave
    Building Photo - 2 Prospect Ave
  • Building Photo - 2 Prospect Ave
    Building Photo - 2 Prospect Ave
$18,000 / Month

2 Prospect Ave

,

Shelter Island, NY 11964

2 Weeks Ago
| Edit
Edit Commute

Under 30 minutes

Commute Time is calculated at rush hour.
Share Listing
Favorites
2 Prospect Ave
Share Listing
Favorites

Check Back Soon for Upcoming Availability

Beds Baths Average SF
2 Bedrooms 2 Bedrooms 2 Br 1 Bath 1 Bath 1 Ba —

Fees and Policies

The fees listed below are community-provided and may exclude utilities or add-ons. All payments are made directly to the property and are non-refundable unless otherwise specified.

Details

Lease Options

  • 12 Months

About This Property

One of 3 cottages on this lovely 2.6 acre estate area property. Newly updated with a living room, large screened/glass dining porch, 2 bedrooms and bath. Crescent Beach area near Perlman Music Center, and Sunset Beach restaurant. [[Rental Registration # 2023-L-0105]]

2 Prospect Ave is a house located in Suffolk County and the 11964 ZIP Code. This area is served by the Shelter Island Union Free School District attendance zone.

House Features

  • Air Conditioning
  • Package Service
  • Laundry Facilities
  • Controlled Access
Location
2 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island,
NY 11964
Get Directions
City - Shelter Island

Nicknamed “the un-Hamptons,” Shelter Island is a peaceful island community situated on the eastern end of Long Island. Shelter Island is only accessible by ferry and sits just five minutes from its bustling neighbor, the Hamptons. Adorned with old-fashioned buildings along tree-lined streets, Shelter Island exudes small-town charm and tranquil luxury in equal measure.

The community’s secluded feel is a part of its allure, despite being within close reach of wine country and the Hamptons. Shelter Island is also roughly a two-hour drive from New York City. Shelter Island’s rental homes generally offer quick access to the community’s many beaches as well as the locally owned shops and restaurants that line Ferry Road.

Learn more about living in Shelter Island 

Below are rent ranges for similar nearby apartments

Beds Average Size Lowest Typical Premium
1 Bed 1 Bed 1 Bed 800 Sq Ft $1,175 $1,185 $1,195
Amenities
  • Air Conditioning
  • Package Service
  • Laundry Facilities
  • Controlled Access
Education
Colleges & Universities Distance
Colleges & Universities Distance
SUNY Suffolk Co., Eastern
Drive: 63 min 28.2 mi
Connecticut College
Drive: 128 min 30.6 mi
University of Connecticut
Drive: 137 min 34.4 mi
Yale University, Main Campus
Drive: 187 min 76.9 mi
2 Prospect Ave is within 63 minutes or 28.2 miles from SUNY Suffolk Co., Eastern. It is also near Connecticut College and University of Connecticut.
Schools
Shelter Island School
Public Elementary, Middle & High School
Grades PK-12
183 Students
Attendance Zone
Our Lady Of Mercy Regional School
Private Elementary School
Grades PK-5
92 Students
Nearby
School data provided by The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.

View GreatSchools Rating Methodology

Data provided by GreatSchools.org © 2026. All rights reserved.
Transportation

2 Prospect Ave is near Tweed/New Haven, located 73.9 miles or 184 minutes away.

Commuter Rail Distance
Commuter Rail Distance
Greenport Station
Drive: 18 min 2.0 mi
Southold Station
Drive: 25 min 6.2 mi
Bridgehampton Station
Drive: 41 min 12.6 mi
Mattituck Station
Drive: 37 min 14.4 mi
East Hampton Station
Drive: 44 min 14.7 mi
Airports Distance
Airports Distance
Tweed/New Haven
 Drive: 184 min 73.9 mi

Walkability Near 2 Prospect Ave Shelter Island, NY 11964

-
Soundscore™
- / 100

Traffic

-

Airport

-

Businesses

-

Scores provided by

HowLoud What is a Sound Score Rating? A Sound Score Rating aggregates noise caused by vehicle traffic, airplane traffic and local sources. How It Works
Points of Interest

Time and distance from 2 Prospect Ave.

Shopping Centers Distance
Shopping Centers Distance
Southold Square
Drive: 25 min 6.2 mi
Village Of Southold
Drive: 25 min 6.2 mi
Lighthouse Center
Drive: 26 min 6.8 mi
2 Prospect Ave has 3 shopping centers within 6.8 miles, which is about a 26-minute drive. The miles and minutes will be for the farthest away property.
Parks and Recreation Distance
Parks and Recreation Distance
East End Seaport Maritime Museum
 Drive: 17 min 1.9 mi
Red House Nature Center
 Drive: 21 min 3.2 mi
Custer Institute Observatory
 Drive: 28 min 7.3 mi
Orient Beach State Park
 Drive: 44 min 12.6 mi
Cedar Point County Park
 Drive: 54 min 15.8 mi
2 Prospect Ave has 5 parks within 15.8 miles, including East End Seaport Maritime Museum, Red House Nature Center, and Custer Institute Observatory.
Hospitals Distance
Hospitals Distance
Stony Brook Eastern Long Island Hospital
Drive: 19 min 2.5 mi
2 Prospect Ave is 2.5 miles and a 19 minute drive from Stony Brook Eastern Long Island Hospital.
Military Bases Distance
Military Bases Distance
Fort Trumbell US Navy
Drive: 129 min 30.2 mi
New London Naval Sub Base
Drive: 137 min 34.1 mi
2 Prospect Ave is 30.2 miles from Fort Trumbell US Navy, and is convenient to other military bases, including New London Naval Sub Base.

You May Also Like

Similar Rentals Nearby

Report an Issue Print Get Directions